Officials Deserve to be Treated Better, Period

After making negative comments toward referees during their loss to Valparaiso this past Friday, Oakland’s Athletics Director and Director of Men’s Basketball Operations were suspended by the Horizon League. They both had to “sit out” Sunday’s game at Illinois-Chicago, which Oakland won. The one game suspension for poor sportsmanship, along with the negative publicity, is a start for a punishment. But all levels of basketball, from youth leagues to high school to college to pro, need to take a firmer stance against all forms of referee abuse. There needs to be a zero-tolerance policy with penalties that actually deter poor behavior, and are not just slaps on wrists. Officials can dole out penalties by issuing technical fouls, and eventually ejections to players and coaches who exhibit poor behavior. But it is not really an official’s job to police fans or administrators. Some people in the stands feel that it is okay to curse, berate, and yell at refs.  For those who act that way toward refs, ponder this question: How would you like it if you are at your desk at work or in a meeting and people start belittling and screaming at you at the office? It probably would be distracting, make for an unpleasant environment, and make completing the work more difficult. (Now I realize that if you don’t ever want to be questioned or spoken to loudly, then officiating is not for you. There just needs to be a much better balance than there is today.)   People need to understand that officiating any sport, especially basketball, is a very difficult job. Officials are human, so they have feelings and are allowed to make some mistakes. Fans who have the urge to scream at refs and yell vulgarities should be thrown out of the arena, and repeat offenders should be barred from future contests.

Most basketball officials have thick skin and can take verbal lashings, but that does not mean they should have to. Oakland’s AD and Director of Basketball Ops should be ashamed of themselves, as they should be held to higher standards than paying customers. Their actions were disgraceful to Oakland University, the Horizon League, and to the game of basketball. But the Horizon League also dropped with ball with the aforementioned weak penalty. C’mon, was their weekend ruined by not having to attend one game at last-place UIC? If the league really wanted to send a message, they would have suspended the duo for the rest of the season. This would include Friday’s rivalry game against Detroit Mercy, the ensuing Horizon League Tournament, and any postseason tournament games as Oakland will definitely get some kind of berth. This suspension, coupled with a monetary fine, would be appropriate. Oakland University should step up and suspend them both for the rest of the season. This would set a strong precedent across the entire country that poor sportsmanship toward referees will not be tolerated by anyone under any circumstances. But since nearly a week has elapsed from the incident, Oakland has dropped the ball too.

For as much as people criticize it for the sometimes lack of exciting games, the NBA does a pretty good job in penalizing abuse toward officials. Players receive progressive fines starting at $2,000 for each technical foul. If a player hits number 16 in a season, he earns a $5,000 fine plus a one game suspension. Mavericks owner Mark Cuban has been fined many times for his very public outbursts toward referees. Players and coaches who choose to criticize referees after games are also met with stiff fines.

Fans need to step up by policing one another in the stands. If someone near you is yelling at the officials, turn around and tell them to cut it out. Use discretion when doing this because some hotheads cannot be reasoned with.  In that case, it is better just to tell someone in arena management or crowd control. People yelling at officials makes for a negative environment that takes away from everyone’s enjoyment of the game. Some states have stepped up to the plate by making it an automatic felony for someone who assaults a game official. Those types of laws are important. But it is the hope that those ugly incidents just would never happen. People sometimes just need to relax and remember that it is just a game. Ironically, it is more than that for officials because they are the gatekeepers of the game.

Officials, such as the three who worked the Oakland/Valpo game, should be commended because they take the high road by not engaging with spectators who yell at them. They had a great game by calling the play on the court fairly and to the best of their abilities, and by displaying constant professionalism and teamwork.  Just because officials will never get every call right, does not mean they will stop trying to. And the respect that officials constantly show others needs to be mutual.

This entry was posted in Courtside Commentary. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Officials Deserve to be Treated Better, Period

  1. Don Seeko says:

    Good commentary Tim. I think that Titan Fans and the rest the Horizon League fans have not been accustomed to this fast play. This style may be one reason why the League is rated lower this year compared to other conferences. Some think the fast play is more exciting, but you just can’t do it for the sake of doing it. Defense usually prevails and Valpo and Wright State are good examples. Wright State has often been a low pre-season pick in years past and yet end up doing well, just like this year. Coach Donlon I suspect may be Coach of the Year regardless of what Wright State does at Joe Louis Arena.

    If WSU advances to the second round, I wonder who they would prefer to play YSU or UDM?


  2. Tim says:

    Thanks Don. Wright State’s last four wins have been close games, so they don’t have much margin for error lately. I think they would rather play YSU. But their first round game will be tough, as I think UIC has improved as much as any team in the league from the beginning of the season to now. It would not surprise me if the Flames pulled off a big first round upset with Dixson’s scoring and having an athletic big man in Odiase.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s